Links :

   site sponsors       

 

   MSI CR52-A2 (MS8352A) 52x24x52 CD-RW

Product :

CR52-A2  MS8352A

Manufacturer :

MSI

Reviewed by :

Wayne Brooker

Price :

$85.00 Approx

Date :

March 10th, 2003.

 

   Page No:   1
              Move to Page :   

 
 

 

 

Introduction

Ask just about anybody what product they think of when they hear the name MSI and I'm betting you'll get one of two replies, motherboards or graphics cards. The fact that MSI also make optical drives is something that many people don't know about, and those of us who do have tended to forget simply because they're not particularly prolific, or at least not in the UK.

When a company as large and well respected as MSI branch out into new product areas you can usually be assured of at least reasonable quality. No successful company with any business sense would jeopardize a hard won reputation for quality by supplementing their product line up with rubbish so although we can be fairly sure the CR52-A2 is good we really need to discover how good!

A quick glance through the drive specs reveals that the MSI marketing department aren't shy when it comes to using acronyms. There's AWSS (Advanced Weighting Suspension System) which is apparently designed to reduce vibration and noise. There's also ROPC (Running Optical Power Control) which it seems is a "technology to avoid writing errors during high-speed CD-Recording by checking the quality of the CD media and automatically selecting the optimum (Maximum) write speed, giving the highest quality results". Next there's EXACT-Rec (Enhanced eXtracting & Adapting Control Technology for Recording) which it's claimed actively monitors record quality and lastly there's BURN-Proof which to be fair is down to Sanyo who developed the technology rather than MSI, and is the name given to their buffer underrun prevention system.

Here's the specs:

Specifications
Special Features

Performance
Data transfer rate
Read: 7800 KB/s (Max.)
Re-Write: 4800 KB/s (Max.)
Write: 7800 KB/s (Max.)
Random Access time: 90 ms (Typical)

Type
Interface: E-IDE/ATAPI UDMA33
Loading: Tray type
Mounting: Horizontal & Vertical

Error rate
Soft read error: < 10-9
Hard read error: < 10-12

Audio performance
Number of channels: 2 (Stereo)
Frequency response: 20 Hz ~ 20 KHz (+0.5dB,-3.0dB)
S/N ratio: > 65 dB (f =1KHz)
Distortion: < 0.5% (LPF 20KHz,f =1KHz)
Output level
Line out: 0.7 Vrms (Typical)
Head phone: 0.7 Vrms (Typical)

Physical Specification
Dimensions (WxHxD): 148.5x42.5x194.2mm
Weigh: <0.86Kg(bare drive)
Power Requirements: DC+5V/+12V, 2.0A (Max.)

Environmental conditions
Temperature:
Operation: +5° to 45°C Non-operation:-20° to + 60°C
Humidity:
Operation: 20% to 80% RH Non-operation: 20% to 90% RH

Reliability
MTBF: > 60000 POH (Duty cycle 25%)

  • BURN-Proof prevents Buffer Under Run
  • EXACT-Rec (Enhanced eXtracting & Adapting Control Technology for Recording) monitors accuracy of writing
  • AWSS (Advanced Weighting Suspension System) Technology reduce vibration & noise.
  • ROPC technology boosts recording reliability
  • Compatible with Windows 95/98/ME/XP/NT4.0/2000
  • Support discs capacity: 790MB(90min)/700MB(80min)/650MB(74min)
    Support discs diameter:8/12cm
  • Disc formats: CD-DA, CD+, CD-ROM/XA, Mixed mode CD, CD-I, Video-CD, Photo CD, CD Extra, CD-TEXT, Bootable CD, CD-MRW
  • Writing Model: Disc At Once, Track At Once, Session At Once, DAO-RAW, Multisession, Packet Writing
  • Fully supports both variable and fixed packet reading and writing (CD-UDF compatible)
  • 52X Max. Read Press CD and CD-R (Data)
  • 48X Max. Read CD-RW
  • Maximum 48X audio extraction
  • Writing CD-R: 4X,8X,12X,16X,20X(CLV) 24X,32X,40X,48X,52X(CAV)
  • Writing CD-RW: 4X,8X,12X,16X(CLV)
    24X,32X(CAV)
  • 2 MB internal buffer
  • ISO 9660 compliant
  • Power-saving feature
  • Motorized easy touch tray loading
  • Build-in headphone jack, volume control Knob and play/ skip button
  • Firmware upgradeable


There's a couple of noteworthy inclusions in the specifications, not least of which is the CR52-A2's support for 790MB or 90 minute media. There's also a fair selection of RW speeds with 4x,8x,16x,24x and 32x available, somewhat better than the rather limiting 4x, 10x and 24x available on the Plextor Plexwriter (PX-W4824TA 48x24x48x) against which I'll be comparing it.

Other than this things look fairly standard. The reliability figures are in line with most other units around as is the 2MB buffer, although the Plextor comes with double this at 4MB. Buffer size is less of an issue since the advent of underrun prevention though it's always nice to have more rather than less.

The lack of Mount Rainier support seems a little odd for such a high end drive but perhaps this is to come in a future firmware revision.

It should also be noted that the upper limit for CD-RW reads and audio extraction is 48x rather than the maximum 52x.

Having looked at the firmware version number, the PCB and allowing for the fact that this drive boasts BURN-proof rather than any of the alternative buffer underrun prevention technologies it appeared to me that the CR52-A2 is based on the Optorite CW5205 which uses the Sanyo LC898095 chipset however MSI reliably inform me that they now manufacture all their own components in-house and that this isn't the case. Don't hold me to it but I've a feeling we could see 32x CD-RW speeds from this drive soon. either officially or with a "hacked" firmware version. I state this because of that slightly teasing product shot that MSI originally used (see top of page) ;)

Bundle

The drive was supplied to me as a bare review unit with a copy of Nero 5.5 so I can't make any real comments on the bundle quality. As I understand it this is pretty much what the retail kit comprises of plus you get a single CD-R and a CD-RW.

The blank media quantity is a little mean but the inclusion of Nero is a good choice, particularly as it offers good support for burning 90 minute media.

 


Home

Website is designed by Mohsin Ali. All graphics is (C) Shapps Technologies 2001-2002.