|

Introduction:::...
In
a warm, dark corner of your PC sits a mysterious little
box of tricks. Underestimated and misunderstood, it
provides the very lifeblood that your PC needs to
function......power.
Of
course if you visit any enthusiast site or forum you'll
hear talk about the importance of an ample supply
of clean power and just how valuable a high quality
PSU is for the stability of your PC, but with even
the sub-£30 budget cases boasting 300 watt or
bigger units fitted as standard just how can you tell
the good from the bad?
In
truth that's a pretty tough question to answer. The
modern power supply is both a very simple yet and
extremely complicated device. The theory behind its
operation isn't rocket science, but the way in which
it has been tweaked, timed and developed makes accurate
testing just about impossible for sites who don't
have access to specialist equipment.
But
all isn't lost. We may not be able to delve into the
psychology of a power supply but that doesn't mean
we can't get a feel for its personality. There are
some telltale signs that almost always identify a
power supply as being a high quality unit and it's
those we'll be looking for. And it's not all about
the number of Watts on offer either!
Today's
candidate is from a company I'm told is quite well
known in Europe, though I can't pretend I'd ever had
any dealings with them in the UK. Tagan, according
to their site, was created by a bunch of guys who
were bitching one day that they couldn't find an off-the-shelf
power supply that met their high standards. So, to
cut a long story short, they starting building some!
The result is a German company captained by a team
of international personnel who want to rule the world.
Okay, I made the last part up, but they do want to
rule the power supply world, and are making some bold
moves to get there.
On
the bench today I have the TG480-U01, a large, black
480 watt unit with some impressive specs and innovative
features. Here's the tale of the tape:

If
that didn't mean a whole lot to you let's pick through
it and see what's important:
Gold
Plated Connectors: Hardly an essential feature
but a nice one all the same. Gold is an excellent
conductor and plating the conductors in gold will
help but it's not quite as essential a feature as
it would be on an audio connector for example.
Twisted
Wires: Not really my field of expertise but I
do know that twisting the cables can reduce EMI quite
significantly. The tightness of the twists can be
pretty critical in how effective this method works
so I'll just have to trust that the guys have done
their homework. What I can say for certain is that
twisted cables do look neater.
Ground
Wire: Power supplies very often ground through
their casing which screws to the chassis anyway so
I'm not certain what the benefits of a separate ground
wire are if any. Tagan state it improves stability
so unless you can enlighten me otherwise I'll have
to assume they're right.
Rubber
Switch Protection: This is an interesting one,
and one that has me a bit baffled. I don't imagine
it's to keep dust out as this would most likely ingress
from inside anyway if it's going to. Nor do I envisage
too many instances where I'll be operating the switch
with wet hands. I guess I'll have to go with the premise
that any protection beats none, though I wish I'd
remembered that before my first was born!
Black
Anodized Heat Sink: Black surfaces radiate and
absorb heat better according to Stefan-Boltzmann
and thus a black heat sink should be more efficient
at cooling the internal components. In actual practice,
black is probably only more efficient under low airflow
situations which, in the case of a thermally or load
controlled fan, will be more often than would normally
be the case otherwise. Anodizing is considered more
effective than painting as the original surface material
is retained and thus the actual surface treatment
can't retain heat as an undesirable side effect.
Wide
Range Input: Some power supplies require you to
throw a selector switch based on the voltage used
in your country. Others accept voltages in a couple
of ranges, usually around 90 to 130V then 190 to 265V.
In the Tagan's case the input voltage can be absolutely
any value between 95 and 250 volt and the power supply
will operate normally.
Active
PFC: Let's keep this one simple. When a power
supply consumes power, not all of it is being used
productively, some of it is simply wasted. The more
efficiently your power supply makes use of the power
it draws the higher its efficiency and the lower the
waste, and thus the lower your electricity bills.
PFC,
or Power Factor Correction, is used to fine tune the
timings of the circuit so that working power and total
power consumed are as closely matches as possible.
In a perfect circuit the PF would be 1.0 (100%). An
average power supply with the less efficient passive
PFC would have a PF value of about 0.75 (75%) while
equipment with no PFC would score about 0.5 (50%).
The
T480-U01 uses active-PFC and rates at up to 0.99 (99%).
OCP,
OVP, SCP, ESD: The "deadly 4". The T480-U01
provides inbuilt protection against over-current,
over-voltage and short-circuit damage. It also shrugs
off electro static discharges up to 3000V.
Lifetime
(MTBF): The MTBF or Mean Time Before Failure is
a pretty meaningless number due the lack of consistency
in testing methods but I think it's fair to assume
this as an average "minimum" lifespan, with
the emphasis being on the word average.
Noise
Control: Most power supplies these days come with
some kind of thermal fan control to help minimise
noise. Tagan use what they call "TSCT" or
Tagan Silence Control technology, which it's claimed
offers an operational volume of only 22dBA at up to
50% load rising to a mere 33dBA when flat out.

DC
Output: It's
a lot easier to make a power supply and its price
tag look good by offering fairly tame DC outputs.
That's clearly not the case with the Tagan as, although
you can find slightly higher +3.3V outputs if you
look hard enough, the 48A available on the +5V line
is bordering on scary.

Perhaps
one of the obvious competitors to the Tagan is Antec's
excellent True Power range. Just for the hell of it,
here's a few spec comparisons between the Tagan and
the True 480, both 480 watt units:
| OUTPUT |
| |
|
+5V
|
-5V
|
+12V
|
-12V
|
+3.3V
|
+5V
SB
|
|
Antec
True480
|
Max.
Load
|
38A*
|
0.5A
|
22A
|
1.0A
|
30A*
|
2A
|
|
Tagan
TG480-U01
|
Max.
Load |
48A |
0.8A |
28A |
1.0A |
28A |
2.5A |
|
Antec
True480
|
Load
Reg.
|
±3%
|
±5%
|
±3%
|
±5%
|
±3%
|
±5%
|
|
Tagan
TG480-U01
|
Load
Reg.
|
±5%
|
±10%
|
±5%
|
±10%
|
±5%
|
±5%
|
|
Antec
True480
|
Ripple
V(p-p)
|
50mV
|
50mV
|
120mV
|
120mV
|
50mV
|
50mV
|
|
Tagan
TG480-U01
|
Ripple
V(p-p)
|
50mV
|
100mV
|
120mV
|
120mV
|
50mV
|
50mV
|
| ENVIRONMENTAL |
|
Antec
True480
|
Tagan
TG480-U01
|
|
Operating
Temp.
|
10
to 50șC
|
0
to 50șC |
|
Operating
Alt.
|
Sea
Level to 10,000 ft.
|
-200
ft to 10,000 ft |
|
MTBF
|
80,000
hrs. @ 25șC
|
100,000
hrs @ ? |
| INPUT |
| |
Antec
True480
|
Tagan
TG480-U01
|
|
Input
Voltage
|
115
VAC / 230VAC
|
95-250VAV |
|
Input
Frequency Range
|
47Hz
to 63Hz
|
47Hz
to 63Hz |
|
Input
Surge Current
|
<
60A @ 115VAC
|
60A/200ms |
|
Hold-up
Time
|
>17ms
at Full Load
|
>20ms
at Full Load |
|
Efficiency
|
>
68%
|
>
70% - 73% |
Nip
and tuck in most cases but the Tagan has the higher
outputs and higher efficiency rating. The Tagan also
has a higher quoted MTBF, for what it's worth, and
a better hold-up time. It comes second best in terms
of its load regulation.
Time
to take a closer look at the unit itself.
|